About us Contact us  
Events Culture Tzavta Campus Resources
 
Education
In Our Community
Direct from Israel
In the Classroom
A Hebrew Moment
On the Bookshelf
Exhibits
Calendar
 
Israel Education Initiative

Archives: In Our Community

October 2005

ipd group  2005Looking for a good textbook to teach Israel to students in your day school or synagogue religious school? Read this article and find out why and how these three educational leaders realized that Heschel was talking to them in his famous and oft-quoted aphorism.

Last summer, three day school educators from Marin, San Francisco and the Peninsula were inspired to create "text people" by conceiving an ambitious plan including a transformational Israel experience, and pre and post trip study.

When Marlo Newton of Brandeis Hillel Day School in Marin, Rachel Lewin of the Wornick Jewish Day School in Foster City and Aviva Joseph of Brandeis Hillel in San Francisco talked about the experience they shared as participants in the year-long professional development program Educational Leadership Institute: focus ISRAEL (E.L.I.), they realized the profound effect it had on the way they thought about teaching (and learning) about Israel. They dreamed of doing something for the teachers in their respective schools that would elicit the same kinds of passion for teaching Israel that they themselves had experienced.

Six months before summer vacation, the three women talked about the unlikely dream of taking a group of 15 teachers and administrators from the three schools to Israel for 10 days in July. They had three goals:

1. To create a community of learners that was diverse, and would be committed to sustained learning before and after the trip.

2. To create "text people" who would embody the experience of Israel in their personal attitudes and behaviors in their classrooms.

Mifgash  20053. To meet, share and establish a long-term relationship with two Israeli schools and the faculty and administration in those schools. (A Mifgash)

Serendipitously, separate sources converged to make this dream a reality: the support and guidance of the Israel Education Initiative in both content, methodology and logistics throughout the entire process, the experience the three women had in their own professional development in E.L.I., the support and buy-in of their own schools and a generous designated donation to the Jewish Community Federation earmarked for professional development in day schools focusing on Israel.

Without all of these conditions, these educators could not have accomplished so much in such a short time.

They had many decisions to make quickly. For example, they had to consider which teachers would participate. They decided to select teachers and administrators who would be certain to put in extra hours required for pre trip seminars and post trip implementation. Besides Jewish participants, they wanted non-Jewish participants who teach general studies in their schools, and hear about Israel constantly, but don't necessarily understand why Israel is so important in Jewish education. They wanted teachers committed to revitalizing the Israel connection for their schools.

Newton, Lewin and Joseph agree that the most commonly heard expression on the trip was: "Now I get it!" Some of these "Aha!" moments were:

• Understanding Jewish passion for the land.
• Understanding the importance of incorporating Israel into the classroom on a regular and integrated way.
• Seeing how Israel has changed since the 1970's.
• Seeing Israel as holy to Christians and Muslims as well as Jews.
• Understanding how Israel is central to Jewish identity.

Dead Sea 2005The trip was rich and complex, as the fifteen participants were encouraged to pursue their interests and develop their own personal stance towards Israel, and then to share their reflections with colleagues. "My favorite moment was walking up to the Nahal David waterfall on the second day. Up to that moment, the trip had been intellectual. When one of the group plunged into the refreshing water after the hot hike, and others followed, we became a community relaxing together. We stopped THINKING about Israel but BECAME Israel. We did what everyone does at Nahal David - we enjoyed the waterfall, and saw each other as people rather than as professional colleagues."

Another commented on her realization that the group was following the old custom of retreating to the desert when faced with dilemmas - "Jews go to the desert to think and to work things out; we have done this as a nation and as individuals, and now in 2005, were doing it again. It was an exhilarating transformation, with the wind in our faces, at twilight, the desert worked its magic."

Another's favorite moment was in the Old City at a Christian holy site. Although she had spent much time in the Old City, this educator had never visited the Christian holy sites. She was especially moved visiting with a colleague who is an observant Christian. "Every day during the school year this teacher shares our Jewish spiritual life; now it was an opportunity for me to share part of her spiritual life at a holy site in Jerusalem."

For the staff of the Israel Education Initiative and E.L.I., Newton, Lewin and Joseph are the "poster children" of that endeavor. They took what they experienced, and used it as a model for creating a similar experience for fifteen teachers and administrators in three day schools. This is success!

Yad Vashem 2005Now they are back, school has started, and dozens of ideas about bringing Israel into the classroom are beginning to be implemented. The ideas are plentiful, from pairing up with an Israeli fourth grade classroom and reading the same book to transforming the walls of a classroom. Classrooms that were formerly bereft of decoration are now bursting with color and energy communicating the vibrancy of Israel. An 8th grade science teacher planned to do a unit on water conservation. After hearing Clive Lipkin of the Arava Institute in Israel, he decided to incorporate a section on how Israel addresses its water shortages in order to naturally integrate Israel into his science curriculum.

Finally, Newton, Lewin and Joseph have these words of advice: "When you have a big, even audacious goal, people start taking you seriously. When you are inspired, you inspire others and your vision begins to grab more people." They knew they would have to put in "volunteer" time over and above the normal hours. The management and boards of their schools were impressed by their dedication and their personal passion. Money was donated, and doors opened to make a dream come true.

***

Read about it in the J. Jewish News weekly (October 7, 2005)

For a personal account of trip participant Ruth Rosenthal click here

Photos by Neal Biskar, head of middle school, BHDS San Francisco

December 2005: Scholars-in-Residence: Interview with Rabbi Elisha Wolfin
by Nechama Tamler

Elisha WolfinHow Teaching Israel Works on Restoring Balance and Other Ruminations
November 16, 2005

NT: Talk to us about the connection between teaching Judaism and teaching Israel:

EW: Before we talk about teaching, perhaps we can talk about living. As an observant liberal Jew who was born, raised, and living in Israel today, I feel there is something profoundly missing about Jewish life there. At the same time, when I lived in the U.S. for a number of years, I felt that something else was lacking here.

I have always regarded Zionism as the deep desire to restore the balance that is absent in Jewish life and existence. Before I became a rabbi, I was in the field of holistic health. Many healing practices and theories are based on an understanding of the four elements--earth, fire, water and air (other systems use additional elements, such as wood and metal). The basic assumption is that a healthy human being needs all four elements to be in balance. The Talmud teaches us that Ha'adam Olam Katan (each person is a small world). What is true for a single human being is also true for a people, or a state.

In very simplistic terms, I would argue that Diaspora Judaism fundamentally lacks the earth element. You can have an environmental activist or a person who loves hiking who nevertheless lacks the earth element. The earth element is about the sense of raw ownership and belonging to the land (any land). You could argue that many city dwellers lack the earth element, but that isn't necessarily true, because it has nothing to do with the physical connection to a plot of earth, but rather, one's profound sense of belonging and ownership of the earth. Now, when one of the four elements is absent, another compensates. In Diaspora Judaism, since the time of the destruction of the Second Temple, the air element compensated for the earth element. In holistic healing, the air element represents intellectualism, cerebral brilliance, and certain forms of spirituality. Jewish brilliance and literacy have been our trademark for centuries. We were both admired and despised for this. It is our very landlessness that produces so many Nobel Prize winners. Landless people excel in their intellectual ingenuity but not in the beautiful crops they grow. However, this brilliance comes with a heavy price tag.

The Zionist revolution was successful in converting the Jewish people from am ha-sefer (people of the book) to am ha'aretz (people of the land). How amusing it is that am ha'aretz is a derogatory term in the eyes of a landless people. The sages, who as a whole, glorified study over agriculture, gave the term am ha-aretz its classical negative connotation; a person who was called an am ha'aretz meant that he was thought of as an uneducated boor. Zionism tried to reverse this, by restoring the Biblical narrative at the expense of the Mishnaic/Talmudic (sages') narrative. Early Zionists did not teach or learn Mishna, where expressions like am ha'aretz received their negative connotation. Instead, they walked the land with a tanakh in hand. The Prophets and the Writings (NaKh), more than the five books of the Torah, were (and still are) a text that glorified the intimate connection between a person and his land-- it is all about a land-based Judaism.

On the other hand, we in Israel today are so land-based that we risk losing the sefer (the book) part of ourselves. While literary brilliance can certainly be found in Israel, there is a sense that the level of education is deteriorating, while children's Jewish education is the Diaspora is on the rise (many more day schools, academic excellence, etc.). Furthermore, as land-based people we run the risk of losing the religious freedom that you American Jews enjoy. Once you have territory you need to govern and rule it. Governing bodies more often than not end up defining the peoples' spiritual path (America is a rare exception to that – it is one of the few places where a separation of Church and State exists). This is indeed what happened in Israel - the State defines who's a Jew and who’s not, and how Jewish life should be lived. This is what happens when the earth element overrides the air element! We lack the Jewish freedom you have in America. In America no governing authority, Jewish or otherwise, can tell you who is Jewish and how Judaism ought to be practiced.

At the end of the day we (Israeli Jews) and you (American Jews) need each other – we will provide a land-based Jewish expression and experience, you will bring Jewish freedom and pluralism, Jewish ingenuity and choice.

One metaphor used when discussing Israel and Judaism, which I think works well, is the body and soul connection…. If the soul is the big idea, the body embodies that big idea. I would like to suggest that Israel can be viewed as the bodily manifestation of Judaism. Living in the Diaspora, teaching Israel could be a way of realizing of giving Judaism a body, a living, breathing reality.

NT: How does one choose what to teach, in particular, about Israel? Through what lens?

EW: Another metaphor from the healing arts can be useful here. Any good education has to be holistic (not from the word holy, but rather from whole, though I like the way the two are intertwined). A profound educational experience touches upon all aspects of life, and of being in the world. Israel can be a living entity in people's psyche if it resonates with the totality of their being. I would hope that each educator personally will be drawn to that which she is passionate about in dealing with Israel. There are very few things that I would not teach in principle (for reasons of ideological censorship, for example). To an extent, a censored life is a life not fully lived.

I am personally drawn to story telling, because stories can capture the nuances and complexities of life. Stories about real life; stories that have dilemmas that suck you into their narrative; stories that remind us how complex, yet exciting, life is. The more complex the better the story, because the more complex the story is, the more we can resonate with it. If Israel is the body and Judaism the soul, then, complex stories can help actualize the theoretical Jewish lessons that are taught in religious schools. In a hypothetical world, Jewish values co-exist beautifully. In a real world that is filled with complexity Jewish values clash (also beautifully...).

Culture and art are another means or another "in" to teaching Israel. Israeli culture and art are rich, potent, alive, colorful and daring (you know Israelis excel in chutzpa). The cultural scene in Israel demands your engagement. Obviously, when you live outside of Israel, daily engagement with Israel is close to impossible; however, rich culture, (high or low), really engages all your senses, your emotions, your belief systems, and your values.

NT: Tell us more about your idea of complexity. How is it a Jewish idea? How does it relate to Israel? How does it relate to teaching Israel?

EW: Israel is extremely complex. This is one of the reasons people shy away from dealing with it. They often feel that it's too impossible, it's too big, it's just too complex. There is so much you need to know in order to understand the most basic realities in Israel. However, the world also is complex! Life is complex!!! Therefore I've come to believe that if we find a way to do it right, complexity can be life enhancing.

If one can regard one's own complex life through the complexity of the Jewish state, then it becomes exciting and familiar, life enhancing, and even fun. As I said earlier, we are taught that each and every person is an entire small world. Each and every person embodies both the beauty as well as the complexity of the entire world.

If there's one thing we can all agree upon, it's that authentic Judaism dares to view life as complex. We often use the expression, "on the one hand and on the other hand". Every profound Jewish encounter echoes this, going back beyond Hillel and Shammai. This is the essence of Jewish discourse, because Judaism recognizes that life is complex and only an authentic system which embraces complexity can be a Torat chayim (a Torah of real life.)

Israel today serves as a great laboratory in which one can play out and experiment with complex ideas. It seems to me that the current American trend tends to simplify and dumb-down reality: everything seems to be solvable; There's always the good guys and the bad guys; There's right and there is wrong; We can fix even the worst and most intractable problems.

NT: Which complexities do you find most compelling and interesting?

EW: Making decisions based on moral values, Jewish values, is very compelling when those values actually clash with each other. You may wonder what is so compelling when values clash? Furthermore, why am I glorifying complexity? Because it makes life fascinating, rich, and deep, as life should be, as Judaism is. We always claim that Judaism echoes life. It does so because it embraces complexity. Well, so does the Jewish State.

In the Diaspora, Jews run synagogues (and Federations, etc.). In Israel Jews run a State! It could happen that one synagogue would have such virulent disagreements among its membership that it would split into two. And that would be fine and would be Jewish--even profoundly Jewish… A Jewish state cannot do that. It cannot break in two (it did 3,000 years ago, and almost a tenth of its population disappeared.

NT: Any last comments?

EW: My perception, and this may not be a polite thing to say, is that there is a lot about American culture that is perfectly content to keep difficult issues at arm's length. Israel, on the other hand, has no such luxury. Difficult issues are always in one's face; Israel provides a very rich and compelling place to experience all of life---its ups, downs, challenges, dilemmas, noise, and "realness". If we do Israel education right, we get people to come to Israel where they can feel the aliveness and complexity for themselves---it’s a wonderful antidote to the "hollywood-ization" of life, where there are just the good guys and the bad guys.

NT: thank you very much, Elisha!


Rabbi Elisha Wolfin, our Scholar-In-Residence, was in the Bay Area for one week during which time he participated in a two day retreat for early childhood educators, led a staff development day in a local day school, spoke to teens at the Peninsula Havurah High in Palo Alto, and worked with a variety of educators as a guest teacher at their November monthly professional development seminars (ELI bet). When this group arrives in Israel later this month with Vavi Toran, director of the Initiative, Elisha will be their local educator. Elisha also visited and worked with the three schools who sent teams to Israel last summer to build twinning programs. The twinning programs are a project of Brandeis Hillel (SF and Marin campuses) and Wornick Jewish Day School locally and in Israel, the Reali School in Haifa and the Misgav School in Misgav.

February 2006

Interview with Cartoonist Michel Kichka

Michel KichkaMichel Kichka, a native of Belgium and the son of survivors of the Sho'ah, came to Israel 32 years ago, and has been cartooning ever since. He is a freelance illustrator of editorial and political cartoons, comic strips, childen's books and advertising. He is also a senior instructor at the Bezalel Academy's Visual Communications Dept. He was recently in the Bay Area as Scholar-in-Residence for the Israel Center, his second such stint, and as one of 20 featured Israeli cartoonists in the San Francisco Cartoon Art Museum, "Israel: The Cartoonists Diagnosis--a View Point From Within."

Q: Isn't cartooning a lonely profession?

A: I am lucky to be part of an international guild of fellow political cartoonists. In a recent meeting in November in Israel, 26 of us from around the world met for a conference discussing everything from the ethics of cartooning to questions we get on a daily basis. It was a chance to expand our thinking. For me, cartooning is more my 'vocation' than my profession but once in awhile, it helps a lot to meet with others in your profession.

Q: Do you think about what's next for you in the world of art?
A: I love what I do, and I use as my model a beloved teacher who taught me illustration, and is still alive, active and drawing at the age of 89. I want to be like her--strong, healthy and to continue expressing my ideas until my last day. I like having the privilege of being able to produce thought-provoking cartoons, and to act the part of the 'court jester'--saying things that are outrageous but spur others to see the absurdities of situations in the news.

Q: Tell us what you think is the point of a political cartoon.
A: A good political cartoon informs. It teaches something. In all learning situations, you can make things much easier for students with humor--you allow your students to enter any subject through the side door--through the door of humor. A cartoon is much more creative than a photograph, for example. Here's an example--let's say you have a photo-op with 50 photographers at a shoot with President Bush and Jacques Chirac--you will emerge with 50 photographs that look very much alike. But, if you put 50 cartoonists in the room and each does a sketch, you will emerge with 50 very different cartoons even though they were all looking at the same thing. That is the power of cartooning.

Q: How should someone look at a cartoon?
A: Cartoons can be read at many different levels. There is the simplest level, and then there is reading-between-the lines. One of the techniques that my favorite American political cartoonist, Pat Oliphant, uses is a little figure, like the penguin, that says something opposite to what the main character is saying. You have to ask yourself, what does the cartoonist mean here? What do the objects symbolize? Cartoonists try to tease their audiences. They are sophisticated and want their pictures to merit and second and even third look.

Q: Can you imagine using cartoons in a classroom?
A: Yes, absolutely, If you just ask a student to tell you what she sees, you will observe that she is actually learning by describing to you everything that is in the picture. Kids don't miss the details--they are better at reading a picture than adults. The student is learning by himself and the teacher finds out what she must fill in as background or context. Teachers need to ask students "tell me what you see" to get a rich discussion going.

Q: So how do you link the subject of your cartoons with the news?
A: In the past 20 years we have become consumers of never-ending news, and I think that fast-news is the same as fast-food--it's not very nourishing. This kind of news is produced by huge media outlets and don't provide thoughtful analysis. We have CNN, the radio talk shows, live news shows--all of which are more like entertainment than news. A cartoonist needs to be much more informed about what is going on and sometimes that means I end up more confused, but it gives me more nuanced view. It is a mistake to think that a cartoon is funny just because it has a lot in common with comics. A political cartoon must be critical, intelligent, sophisticated. A cartoon is print media--it stays around and is exposed for a much longer time.

Q: What process do you use?
A: One of the classic ways to work is to juxtapose two subjects, for example, war or a natural disaster with something trivial happening in Hollywood. It is out of this strange pairing that something interesting happens and gets people to re-think. After Sharon was hospitalized with a stroke all of the political satire shows were off the air for a week in Israel. There was an atmosphere of mourning, similar to the way it was after Rabin was shot ten years ago. But the cartoonists didn't stop because we have a different sense of responsibility. What we wanted to say made people stop and think--whereas a TV show just disappears when it is off the air. We are in the business of researching the naked truth.

Q: I want to ask you about the cartoons printed in the Danish press that outraged the Muslim world.
A: This is a dramatic example of the power of cartoons. Cartoons are stronger than editorials because they are immediate. It takes 5 minutes to read an editorial and people don't bother, but a cartoon--it just takes 1-2 seconds to read a cartoon--and everyone has time for that. I am so glad to live in a country without censorship. A friend in France who works for Le Monde must submit 4 or 5 cartoons daily to his editor, who then decides what can be printed. In Israel, we have 'personal censorship' ; we know the limits of good taste and each cartoonist draws his own line, so to speak. I am the son of survivors of the Sho'ah, and I made a personal pledge to avoid the Sho'ah in my drawings, but, one day, I felt very strongly about something and I broke my own rule to make a point.

Q: What is your relationship with print journalists?
A: We cartoonists are not really journalists---but we depend on them. And yet, we are much more exposed, because we only represent ourselves rather than the country or the newspaper. Israel is a very good place to be a cartoonist--a democracy--and it is very important not to get caught up in one party that you completely identify with because you risk becoming a propagandist. For eight years, I cartooned on TV on a morning show and drew a cartoon based on the morning's headlines; at the end of the show, I displayed what I had come up with during the taping. When I left the studio, I felt exposed for a second time because presumably anyone watching the TV show saw me showing my work on TV and now they knew exactly what I looked like. People recognized me on the street and so I tried to censor myself on TV--but not too much. It made an interesting life.

Michel Kichka was interviewed by Nechama Tamler in San Francisco, February 6, 2006

Interview with Stuart Schoffman
Journalist and columnist with the Jerusalem Report

Michel KichkaStuart Schoffman, graduate of Yale, Harvard and as he reminds you, "the yeshiva of Flatbush" made Aliyah from Brooklyn to Jerusalem over 25 years ago. A journalist with a keen mind, well versed in traditional Jewish thought and history and an active member of the Screenwriters Guild of America, Schoffman is currently serving as the volunteer chair of the San Francisco Jewish Community Federation's Amuta, non-profit advisory board in Israel that helps guide the allocation of grants to worthwhile efforts in Israeli society. Schoffman also pointed out that he has a soft place in his heart for Jewish educators, since he is the son of two of them.

Q: What is the most important thing a Jewish educator can teach about Israel?
A: "Students need the broadest possible picture of Israel, one which is complete with all of her triumphs and all of her vulnerabilities. The State of Israel represents the ongoing normalization of the Jewish people as a nation among the nations of the world. We need to teach American Jewish kids that there glories and pitfalls to Jewish sovereignty and that we have come a very long way from the days of the folk-dancing heroes and the swamp-drainers.”

Q: What are Israelis talking about vis a vis the political situation currently?
A: “We in Israel are full-time, full-strength Jews living in our own land and coping with huge political changes at the moment. These political realities are impossible for the average citizen to control, but this is not a new phenomenon. In Israel, it is often the case that the toughest social problems are eclipsed by the big issues of security and politics. We can't fix Teheran getting nuclear weapons, or the undoing of the terrorist agenda of Hamas, but we can work on the issues that go towards our shared values.” Schoffman insists we focus on the things we can control. "We can promote education for democracy, with 'one citizen, one vote.' We can pursue the idea of religious pluralism and social justice. We can demand equality of economic opportunities for all of Israel's citizens, not just for the white, ashkenazi, anglo-saxons (WASPS). We need to continue finding those start-up initiatives which will bring the values of civil liberties and justice to the table in Israeli society."

Q: Could you give us an example?
A: "There are lots of examples. Here's one: we need to provide day care for Arab children because if we don't do it and the government doesn't do it, who will? And if no one does it, aren't we adding to building an indigenous movement parallel to Hamas within our own cities?"

Q: What do you think about the future of Kadima (Ariel Sharon's new political party)?
A: "Look, Sharon is now literally hovering between heaven and earth and therefore it's exceedingly difficult to say anything until the dust settles. However I believe there was a great deal of national momentum in favor of Kadima. But Kadima was not yet a political party of substance when Sharon suffered his stroke. Not much was planned and now he has already begun to be deified among the popular press. Sharon was a larger-than-life presence and even in his incapacitated state, he seems to exert enormous influence. Even people on the left in Israeli politics realize that an important part of Sharon's legacy was the withdrawal from Gaza--completed without bloodshed and internecine fighting. Sharon rode the wave of consensus that this was tremendously painful but had to happen. He finally realized that he could have two of the following three realities: 1) a Jewish state 2) a democratic state 3) a state that had limited borders (not the Greater Land of Israel.) He made the decision to get out of Gaza, in order to keep the State of Israel Jewish and democratic."

Q: And what do you think about how Ehud Olmert has assumed the role of Prime Minister?
A: "Olmert is now wearing the cloak of his predecessor. Anyone would have a hard time stepping into that. The Israeli elections are just weeks away (end of March); we need to keep a close eye on the moves of Hamas--what are they going to do?" Schoffman maintains that it won't work to have the separation between Israel and the territories be along the lines of "we're here and they're there and we're also there," warning that the withdrawal needs to take the new realities of Hamas into account.

Q: But aren't you really worried about this terrorist organization being the parliamentary majority of the Palestinian Authority?
A: "Look--its normal and natural to be alarmed but I don't want to become an alarmist! As far as Hamas goes, we might be looking at a Nixon-in-China phenomenon; it's important to think through what it means to withhold money from Hamas just because they are a terrorist organization. Do we want hungry, angry young men with guns on the loose? Who are they going to take their anger out on? And furthermore, what can we learn from history? The last time a giant leader fell in Israel was ten years ago, when Yitzhak Rabin was shot. Shimon Peres refused to campaign as the one who would make good on the legacy of Rabin and that's why he lost the election. That was fateful because it turned Netanyahu into the next Prime Minister. A second intifada brought more violence; only later we saw Sharon as a political leader that was trusted more by the public. Sharon was able to contain terrorism and also make the necessary moves to "divorce" Israel from the Palestinians, starting with the Gaza withdrawal without the same hyperbole as Netanyahu."

Q: So what's the most important thing to teach our kids about Israeli politics?
A: "Focus on what's really important and what's in your control: teach the complexity of the moment facing Israel, but more important, teach values that we share and that we want to support in Israel. Teach social justice for Israel as well as for American Jews. Teach about the "haves" and "have-nots" in Israeli society, and what we can do about it. Teach about helping bring about better economic conditions for the 34 % of Israeli children who live below the poverty line. Teach that social justice means social justice for every human being, not just for the Jewish Israelis, but for the Arab Israelis as well. This is an important voice for us to convey to our students."

Stuart Schoffman was interviewed by Nehcama Tamler in Palo Alto, January 30, 2006

 

The IEI is a join project of the Israel Center of the Jewish Community Federation, Bureau of Jewish Education and North American Coalition for Israel Engagement. The project is supported by a grant from the Koret Foundation.